Recruitment Marketing Budget as a Percentage of Gross Profit – Are Times Changing Again?

Over the last three months we’ve been touring Australia and New Zealand with Recruitment Yarns – it was great to see the number of senior recruitment leaders who are very passionate about their recruitment agency’s brand. One of the most frequent questions we were asked during the tour was around recruitment marketing budgets, specifically ‘what should be spent on marketing delivery and paid advertising?’ For most recruitment agencies, the largest marketing expenditure is dedicated to candidate attraction, historically this was focused on newspaper adverts but today is almost exclusively online job boards. Other significant marketing expenses can include the marketing delivery (either in-house or outsourced), collateral, sponsorships, events, exhibitions or online advertising. Note that I say “can” include for the second group. This is because it is still very common for an agency’s marketing activity to be limited almost entirely to job boards. If anything additional is undertaken, it is done with very little strategy, with direction generally coming from the Business Directors and implementation spread across the administration function. There is nothing wrong with the approach outlined above, however we’re now seeing a new breed of recruitment agencies that are taking advantage of this complacency, by investing in marketing as a competitive tool to support them as they very quickly scale their business and become some of the most recognisable brands in their sector/s. To achieve these results they have had to look at marketing in a different light, especially when it comes to budget.

Recruitment Marketing Budget as a Percentage of Gross Profit

One of the best ways of ensuring you are keeping up with industry is to track marketing spend as a percentage of gross profit*. To find out what this figure looks like throughout Australia and New Zealand we approached RIBreport. Interestingly, the RIBreport data shows that pre-Global Financial Crisis (GFC), the median marketing spend as a percentage of gross profit was 8%. This figure is in-line with global data outside of the recruitment sector which suggests between 7% and 8% is a good guideline, although obviously this can vary greatly depending on the size, marketing position and future plans of the business. However, in the recruitment sector, after the GFC this percentage declined to less than 5% by 2010 and hasn’t increased significantly since. The main reason for the initial decline is the obvious need to cut expenditure during tougher economic times. It is surprising though that this figure didn’t recover in-line with the economy. Whilst there are many potential reasons for this, alongside increased efficiencies, the rapid decline in the usage of comparatively expensive client paid print advertising is likely the other main culprit. This is because it was common to on-charge the cost of the advertising to the end-client and for the five-year period from 2010 to 2015, there were very few alternatives available, so this marketing avenue ceased to exist. Recruitment Marketing Budget as a Percentage of Gross Profit

All Change?

With the rise in popularity of online or digital advertising for both candidate attraction and branding there are now more marketing opportunities available and we have observed recruitment agencies starting to take advantage of this. As an example, only in the last 12-18 months has LinkedIn, the industry’s marketing barometer, begun to sell marketing orientated packages directly to recruiters. These include channels typically utilised by consumer marketing, such as sponsored content packages and leads capture pages. We’re also starting to see a new generation of digital co-branded client paid advertising appearing, with custom video and graphic design content playing a key part in this. It is still too early to draw any hard conclusions from a data perspective, but the RIBreport figures for the first part of 2017 do show a very slight increase from the year prior (+0.3%).

Rule of Thumb

Whilst the ratio of marketing budget to gross profit may not ever jump back to pre-GFC levels, if you want to create a competitive advantage for your agency through marketing, then it is essential to allocate budget not only for job advertising, but also for the strategy and delivery. Things like written content, video, Pay Per Click or Pay Per Impression advertising, social media management and newsletters all require more time and coordination than the marketing approaches of 10 or even 5 years ago. Our general rule of thumb is that your total marketing budget should factor in between one point five and two times the salary or cost of your marketing function for advertising and talent attraction (including job boards), usually with an even split across the two. If your business is in an aggressive growth mode or requires greater visibility in a shorter space of time this ratio will remain consistent but the overall percentage of gross profit may increase. Lastly don’t be afraid to remain responsive throughout the year. Setting a marketing budget at the start of the year and sticking rigidly to it doesn’t allow you to be agile, it needs to be reviewed regularly (quarterly) and sometimes new projects may need to be added which could take you above the set percentage but are in line with market changes or innovations.

Summary

For those of you old enough to remember when the key topic of discussion was whether or not to embrace a new concept called online job boards, the same outcome is inevitable when it comes to digital marketing. Over the last three years we’ve already seen many real-world examples of how this new approach to recruitment marketing can significantly increase key metrics such as increased volumes of jobs and better job fill ratios. Don’t get left behind.     *In this article, gross profit is defined as permanent recruitment fees plus temporary margin, and margin from any other activities.

Chris South

As Director of Prominence, Chris is the first-person recruiters speak to when trying to get a handle on their marketing activity. He is also highly involved in the day to day delivery on all client accounts, but is slowly learning to let his fantastic team take care of business and to only interfere when needed! Based in Auckland, Chris travels to Australia monthly, meaning he has a lot of air miles and has also seen every new film. However, he is the first to tell you that the life of a frequent traveller isn’t quite as glamorous as it seems! Chris is inspired by people that break the mould and try to make things better.

More Posts

Follow Me:
TwitterLinkedIn

You may also like

Leave a comment

Tracking & Measurement

Monthly analytics reporting on campaign performance through platform analytics, data includes impressions, click rate, conversion rate, specific keyword and individual advert performance, landing page results and call metrics.

×
Conversion Rate Optimisation

It’s the most important element in a successful campaign and the old saying ‘you snooze, you lose’ is very apt and it’s where most fail. Using the analytics data we continue to test and refine the campaigns to increase conversation rates and therefore the results for your recruitment business.

This includes:

×
Phone Call Tracking

A large percentage of both Display and SEM generates phone calls to your recruitment business or individual recruiters. Because of this, usually this is where the ability to track return on investment ceases. However on all of our campaigns we enable a proprietary piece of technology that tracks and records each phone call. Not only can we now track the success of each call, we can give you access to the call recording platform to use the calls as training and service improvement tools.

×
Customised Landing Pages

A digital advertising campaign without a landing page is a bit like a candidate with an unexplained gap in their CV. There is a chance it will be ok, but also a big risk that it won’t. We use our own landing page tool to create customisable experiences that are centered on generating outcomes. They also allow us carry out conversion rate optimisation (CRO), to increase Google Quality Scores and to split (A/B) test different concepts.

×
Advert Design & Copywriting

The success and failure of a digital advertising campaign often relies on the quality of the advert itself. Using our in-house design and copywriting teams we’re able to create the very best visual and copy based adverts. This is across a range of mediums, from text and static images to moving GIF/HTML5 files and even video.

×
Research & Analysis

We use all the available tools and our recruitment industry experience to ensure we fully understand your business goals. As a certified Google Partner we are also able to produce industry insights created by our dedicated Account Managers within Google, which are directly passed on to you.

×
Tracking & Measurement

Monthly analytics reporting on campaign performance through platform analytics, data includes impressions, click rate, conversion rate, specific advert performance, landing page results and call metrics.

×
Conversion Rate Optimisation

It’s the most important element in a successful campaign, and the old saying ‘you snooze, you lose’ is very apt, and it’s where most fail. Using the analytics data, we continue to test and refine the campaigns to increase conversation rates and therefore the results for your recruitment business.

This includes:

×
Phone Call Tracking

A large percentage of Social Media Advertising campaigns generate phone calls to your recruitment business or individual recruiters. Because of this, usually this is where the ability to track return on investment ceases. However, on all of our campaigns we enable a proprietary piece of technology that tracks and records each phone call. Not only can we now track the success of each call, we can give you access to the call recording platform to use the calls as training and service improvement tools.

×
Customised Landing Pages

A social media advertising campaign without a landing page is a bit like a candidate with an unexplained gap in their CV. There is a chance it will be ok, but also a big risk that it won’t. We use our own landing page tool to create customisable experiences that are centered on generating outcomes.

×
Advert Design & Copywriting

The success and failure of a social media advertising campaign often relies on the quality of the advert itself. Using our in-house design and copywriting teams we’re able to create the very best visual and copy based adverts. This is across a range of mediums, from text and static images to moving GIF/HTML5 files, Facebook Canvas adverts and even video.

×
Case Study Request

×